
Why Stand with Israel
WHY DOES THE CHURCH KEEP TELLING ME
I HAVE TO SUPPORT ISRAEL?
A personal examination and current struggle with Scripture, history,
modern Israel, Palestine, and Christian allegiance
I came home from church troubled today. From Ignite Church.
For all of my Christian life, I have heard the same refrain:
Bless Israel.
Stand with Israel.
Support Israel.
My pastor had just returned from Israel. A US-Pastor trip, paid for by Israel, and once again I found myself confronted with the enormous place Israel occupies in American evangelical Christianity.
And something inside me finally asked:
What exactly am I being commanded to support?
Because I need to make something very clear before going any further.
I do not hate Jewish people.
I reject antisemitism.
I recognize the unimaginable evil perpetrated against Jewish people throughout history, culminating in the Holocaust.
I also recognize there is so much more to that historical perspective that has surprised me.
I also know we have been lied to about History. (Which Parts though!)
AND:
I honor the Jewish ancestry of my own faith.
My Messiah was Jewish.
The apostles were Jewish.
The prophets were Jewish.
The Scriptures that prepared the world for Jesus came through Israel.
I cannot separate Christianity from Israel without destroying Christianity itself.
But..... none of that answers my question.
Does loving Jewish people require me to support the modern Israeli government?
And where exactly did Christians get the idea that Genesis 12:3 requires me to do so?
“I WILL BLESS THOSE WHO BLESS YOU”
This is usually where the discussion ends.
God tells Abraham:
“I will bless those who bless you.”
I believe Him.
The question is not whether the verse is true.
Who is “you,” and what does “bless” mean under the New Covenant?
Because the Bible did not end in Genesis.
Paul takes us directly back to Abraham in Galatians 3 and says something extraordinary.
The promise to Abraham was already announcing the Gospel.
And the promised Seed ultimately points to Christ.
Then......
Paul says that those who belong to Christ are Abraham's offspring—heirs according to the promise.
And........
That changes the conversation.
The road from Abraham does not terminate in a flag.
It terminates in Jesus Christ.
So how did an Abrahamic promise become a twenty-first-century foreign-policy commandment?
I genuinely want someone to show me.
WHO IS ISRAEL?
This is where it becomes difficult for me.
Paul writes:
Romans 9:6.
“For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel.”
Paul’s point is that physical descent from Israel does not automatically equal belonging to the covenant people of God in the fullest spiritual sense.
The surrounding passage, especially Romans 9:6–8, develops that distinction between natural descent and the “children of the promise.”
He distinguishes outward identity from inward covenant reality.
Shouldn't we also do this?
He speaks of circumcision of the heart.
Gentile believers are grafted into the olive tree.
But then Paul immediately warns us:
Do not boast against the natural branches.
That warning matters.
Christianity gives me absolutely no permission to despise Jewish people. None.
But Christianity also gives me no permission to pretend that rejecting Jesus Christ doesn't matter.
Rabbinic Judaism does not confess Jesus as Messiah.
Christianity does.
That is not some minor theological disagreement.
Jesus is the center of Christianity.
He said: “I am the way, the truth, and the life.”
There isn't one road to God for Gentiles and another for Jews.
There is one Messiah.
John 14:6
“Jesus said to him, ‘I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.’”
And this is where I also have to distinguish biblical Israel from rabbinic Judaism.
The Talmud is not my Old Testament.
Christianity's roots run through Abraham, Moses, David, the prophets and the Hebrew Scriptures—and all of them ultimately lead me to Jesus.
Later rabbinic tradition is something different.
That doesn't make Jewish people my enemy.... It does means we disagree about the most consequential question imaginable:
Who is Jesus Christ?
And Yes, Jesus was rejected.
Jewish religious authorities participated in the rejection and condemnation of Jesus.
Roman authority sentenced Him. Roman soldiers crucified Him.
But Scripture takes us somewhere deeper than assigning ethnic blame.
Jesus said:
John 10:18
“No one takes it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself.”
He went willingly.
Ultimately, it is my sin that required that cross too.
Calvary is where I discover how desperately I needed the Jewish Messiah myself.
THEN.... I STARTED READING THE MODERN HISTORY
And this is where my questions became harder.
I had learned about the biblical history of Israel.
I knew nothing about the creation of the modern State of Israel.
Those are not the same story.
That Holocaust is almost impossible to comprehend.
The world's sympathy for Jewish refugees after that catastrophe is completely understandable.
Palestine?
But another people were already living in Palestine.
Muslims. Christians. Jews.
Families with houses, businesses, farms, churches, villages and generations of history.
And once I began listening to Palestinian testimony, I encountered stories I had never heard in church: stories of families who lived beside Jewish immigrants; stories of hospitality, welcoming the abused Jewry into their homes.... finding the saved Jews had changed the locks and kicked their hosts right out of their personal homes.
In some cases, the locks literally had been changed.
That image has stayed with me: the key that no longer opens the door.
Stories told by living voices of this time and these events!
The twentieth century produced an almost unbearable human paradox:
A people desperately seeking refuge after persecution became part of a political transformation that produced another population of refugees.
Recognizing that does not diminish the Holocaust.
It doesn't erase Jewish suffering.
It simply refuses to erase Palestinian suffering in order to honor Jewish suffering.
Surely Christians are capable of grieving both.
And Then... I rediscovered Balfour.
This part stopped me too.
Political Zionism did not always treat the eventual territory of a Jewish homeland as politically settled.
“Theodor Herzl, the founder of modern political Zionism, openly considered both Palestine and Argentina as possible territories for a future Jewish state.”
Britain later proposed territory in East Africa—the famous Uganda Scheme.
That proposal was eventually rejected.
Palestine became the objective.
Then in 1917 came the Balfour Declaration.
The British government announced support for establishing a Jewish “national home” in Palestine.
There was MUCH politicking behind this!
That wasn't Scripture speaking.
That was the British Empire.
And the same declaration explicitly said that nothing should prejudice the civil and religious rights of the existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine.
That fact raises an enormous question for me.
If what happened in 1948 was the direct fulfillment of biblical prophecy, where exactly does Scripture establish that connection?
The fact that early Zionists considered alternative territories does not prove that God wasn't working providentially.
God can accomplish His purposes through people who have no idea they are accomplishing them... Like Jonah. Like Nahum.
But neither can I simply work backward:
Israel exists. Therefore God created it.
Therefore 1948 fulfilled prophecy.
Therefore the modern State equals biblical Israel.
Therefore Genesis 12:3 applies to its government.
Therefore Christians must support that government.
There are several enormous theological equals signs in that argument.
I want to examine every one of them to do my best to unwinde my heart and entangled understandings.
Because 1948 was not Genesis 12
The establishment of modern Israel came through a complicated sequence of modern political events: Zionism. European antisemitism. Ottoman collapse. British imperial policy. The Balfour Declaration. Migration. Arab resistance. Partition. Civil conflict. War. Displacement. Statehood.
I am of course NO EXPERT, just beginning to really question why Israeli flags are everywhere in my country and in my churches.
Maybe God's providence was working through all of it.
Maybe 1948 really does have prophetic significance.
I am open to that.
But if you tell me it does, don't simply point at that Israeli flag.
Open the Bible.
Show me Ezekiel.
Show me Isaiah.
Show me Jeremiah.
Show me Amos.
Show me Zechariah.
Show me Romans.
And let us read the entire passage.
Because here's the test I increasingly want to apply:
If I had read that prophecy in 1800—
before Herzl, before Balfour, before the Holocaust, before 1948—
would the biblical text itself have caused me to predict what happened in 1948?
If yes, that is powerful evidence.
If not, perhaps we are reading history backward into Scripture.
I want to know which.
I need help.
BECAUSE.... JERUSALEM WON'T LEAVE ME ALONE
And this is where I cannot simply swing to the opposite conclusion.
Because there is another easy answer:
“Israel doesn't matter anymore. The Church replaced Israel. Finished.”
I cannot get comfortable with that either.
Because Jerusalem keeps appearing.
Zechariah points toward Jerusalem.
Prophecy points toward Jerusalem.
Jesus ascends near the Mount of Olives. And Acts tells us:
Acts 1:11
“This same Jesus, who was taken up from you into heaven, will so come in like manner as you saw Him go into heaven.”
OKAY -> That stops me.
Because Jesus isn't returning to America.
He isn't returning to Rome.
He isn't returning to London.
And He isn't returning to Murrells Inlet.
The biblical story keeps dragging my attention back toward Jerusalem and the Mount of Olives.
Why?
If geography became completely irrelevant after Christ, why does Jerusalem remain so prominent in biblical prophecy?
I don't have a neat answer.
And I'm becoming suspicious of people who do.
And then comes an even more uncomfortable question
What if some of my end-times assumptions are wrong too?
Jesus repeatedly used language about things happening within “this generation.”
Jerusalem and the Temple were catastrophically destroyed in AD 70.
So how much of Matthew 24 happened then?
What did Jesus mean by “coming”?
What does Revelation mean when it speaks of things that must “shortly” take place?
When exactly is Satan bound?
What is the thousand years?
And what is the mysterious “little season” after Satan is released in Revelation 20?
Why was Daniel told to close the scroll as its time was not here yet, and John was told not not close the scroll because the time is at hand.
Daniel 12:4
“But you, Daniel, shut up the words, and seal the book until the time of the end…”
Daniel 12:9
“Go your way, Daniel, for the words are closed up and sealed till the time of the end.”
Revelation 22:10
“And he said to me, ‘Do not seal the words of the prophecy of this book, for the time is at hand.’”
These questions have led some Christians toward preterist interpretations of prophecy.
And eventually the truly disruptive question appears:
Could more prophecy already have been fulfilled than I was taught?
Could Christ's “coming” language in some passages refer to first-century judgment?
Could our conventional prophetic timeline be wrong?
And then comes the enormous question:
Could Jesus already have returned in the sense some interpreters claim?
I am not prepared to declare that.
The bodily resurrection, Acts 1, Revelation's language about Christ being seen, the final judgment and Paul's teaching about death being defeated create enormous problems for a completely fulfilled eschatology.
But I am no longer afraid to examine it.
Although it is exhausting and isolating from my old friends.
Scripture gets to overturn my theology.
My theology doesn't get to overturn Scripture.
So wheredoes that leave Israel?
Somewhere considerably more complicated than the slogans....
I can say all of these things simultaneously:
I love Jewish people, because I love people as commanded.
I condemn antisemitism.
I grieve the Holocaust.
I recognize the Jewish people's ancient connection to the land.
I recognize the suffering and dispossession of Palestinians.
I recognize that Palestinian Christians exist and confess the same Jesus I do.
I recognize that rabbinic Judaism rejects Jesus as Messiah.
I recognize that the New Testament grafts Gentile believers into Abraham's covenant story.
I recognize that Paul warns those Gentiles never to become arrogant toward the natural branches.
And I recognize that Jerusalem somehow remains enormously important in the biblical story.
None of those propositions requires me to hate anybody.
But neither do they require me to surrender discernment.
So please stop giving me the Slogan: Bless Israel.
Fine. Tell me what you mean.
Love Jewish people? Yes.
Oppose antisemitism? Absolutely.
Grieve murdered Israeli civilians? Of course.
Grieve murdered Palestinian civilians? Exactly the same answer.
Pray for Jerusalem? Yes.
Pray for Jewish people? Yes.
Pray for Palestinians? Yes.
Honor the people through whom God brought the Messiah into the world? Absolutely.
But if by “Bless Israel” you mean support the government of Israel because Genesis 12:3 commands Christians to do so—
Show me.
If modern Israel is the prophetic restoration of biblical Israel—show me.
If 1948 fulfills Ezekiel—show me the entire chapter.
If Romans 11 requires the establishment of a modern Jewish nation-state—show me.
If criticizing an Israeli government policy means I am opposing God—show me.
I am willing to be corrected.
I am willing to be taught.
What I am no longer willing to be is sloganeered.
SO-> WHY PALESTINE?
Before I can say, “Christians must support Israel,” I have to ask a question I am never encouraged to ask:
Why Palestine? And how did we get here?
So I have learned that for centuries, Palestine was part of the Ottoman Empire.
Arabs—Muslim and Christian—lived there, alongside longstanding Jewish communities.
Jewish connection to this land is ancient and undeniable.
But modern Israel did not simply appear because Jews “returned to the land God gave them.”
There was a political history in between.
During World War I, Britain encouraged Arab hopes for independence if they helped defeat the Ottoman Empire. While those conversations were taking place, Britain and France were secretly negotiating how much of the defeated Ottoman territory they would control.
Control.
Lies.
Oil and power.
Deceit.
Same ol' same ol'.
Ecclesiastes 1:9
“That which has been is what will be,
That which is done is what will be done,
And there is nothing new under the sun.”
Then, in 1917, Britain issued the Balfour Declaration, supporting “the establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people.”
There was one two enormous problems:
Britain did not own Palestine.
And the people already living there were overwhelmingly Arab.
So I Think about that.
European powers were negotiating borders, spheres of influence, and national futures for people thousands of miles away—while the people actually living on that land had remarkably little power over what was being decided.
Then came Hitler.
Then the Holocaust.
Six million Jews (they say) (as well as Christians and others) were murdered in Europe, and the cry for a Jewish homeland became unimaginably urgent.
Yes, I understand that cry.
But another question haunts me:
Why were Palestinians required to pay the territorial price for a crime committed against Jews by Europeans?
That does not erase Jewish suffering.
It does not erase Jewish history.
It does not erase the Jewish connection to Jerusalem.
And it certainly does not justify the violence committed against Jews.
But neither can Jewish suffering erase Palestinian suffering.
By 1947, the United Nations proposed dividing Palestine into Jewish and Arab states.
War followed. Israel was established.
Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians became refugees—some fleeing battle and fear, others expelled or prevented from returning to homes and villages they had inhabited before the war.
Palestinians call that catastrophe the Nakba.
And suddenly the story I had been given became so much more complicated.
Because Palestinians did not appear in 1948.
And Jewish connection to the land did not appear in 1917.
Both peoples have history there.
Both peoples have buried their dead there.
Both peoples have suffered there.
But European governments also made decisions, promises, secret agreements, mandates, and borders that helped turn competing national aspirations into a catastrophe whose consequences remain with us.
And even with my beginning study.... that matters enormously to me as a Christian.
Because I cannot take decisions made by British politicians, European diplomats, the League of Nations, or the United Nations and retroactively stamp across them: “Thus saith the Lord.”
The Balfour Declaration is not Scripture.
Sykes-Picot is not prophecy.
A British Mandate is not a biblical covenant.
And a United Nations partition resolution is not a decree from God.
So before someone tells me that supporting every territorial or military claim of the modern State of Israel is my biblical obligation, I need them to show me where Jesus said that.
Because Jesus did say something unmistakably clear:
John 14:6
“I am the way, the truth, and the life. No one comes to the Father except through Me.”
And Paul wrote something arresting and super clear to me:
Romans 9:6
“For they are not all Israel who are of Israel.”
That is where my question has finally landed.
For now.
Not:
Do I love Israel or Palestine?
But:
Can I love the Jewish people, grieve the Holocaust, condemn antisemitism, recognize their ancient connection to the land—and still look honestly at what happened to the Palestinian people?
I believe I must.
Because if I have to hide history to defend my theology, then I need to examine my theology.
THERE IS ONLY ONE NATION I WILL NEVER QUESTION
And it isn't America.
And it isn't Israel.
In fact, it isn't a nation at all.
There is only one King whose actions I will never place under moral judgment.
Jesus Christ.
I do not bow to Washington. Nor Jerusalem.
I do not bow to Republicans. Nor Democrats.
I do not bow to Zionism. Nor anti-Zionism.
I do not bow to dispensationalism. Nor preterism.
I do not bow to the theological traditions of my church.
I bow to Jesus.
And wherever His Word takes me, I want to go.
If Scripture proves that modern Israel occupies a specific prophetic role, I want to believe it.
If Scripture shows that I have confused a modern political state with biblical Israel, I want to know that too.
If I've misunderstood Matthew 24, correct me.
If I've misunderstood Romans 11, correct me.
If I've misunderstood Revelation, correct me.
I don't want a pro-Israel theology.
I don't want an anti-Israel theology.
I want a true theology.
And after all of these questions, something still fascinates me.
My eyes keep returning to Jerusalem.
The place of David. The city of the prophets.
The place where Jesus entered riding on a donkey.
The place where He was rejected.
The place outside which He was crucified.
The place near which He ascended.
And somehow, mysteriously, the place toward which biblical prophecy keeps directing our attention again.
I don't yet completely understand why.
So I read. I write. I ask.
Not because I hate Israel.
Not because I hate Jewish people.
But because I love Jesus enough to question what people tell me about Him.
My allegiance belongs neither to Israel nor Palestine. Neither Jew nor Gentile can save me.
Neither government can save me. Neither political movement can save me.
Only Jesus Christ can do that.
So when someone tells me: “You must stand with Israel,” my answer has changed:
I will stand with truth.
I will stand against hatred.
I will stand with innocent people.
I will stand with Scripture.
And above everything else—
All I Truly Know....
I will stand with Jesus.
Joshua 24:15
And if it seems evil to you to serve the Lord, choose for yourselves this day whom you will serve, whether the gods which your fathers served that were on the other side of [a]the River, or the gods of the Amorites, in whose land you dwell.
But as for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.”
But as for me and my house, we will serve the Lord.”


Comments (0)
Join the conversation
Be the first to share your thoughts on this post
No comments yet
Start the discussion and be the first to comment